For Sale, Again


Libby’s New Horizon Acquisitions LLC purchased the landmark at 377 Main Street for $2.05 million. It is now listed with Robert Rocheeld of Century 21 Best, Inc. of Elmhurst, NY for $3,999,999.
Long Island-based Libby had announced ambitious plans for 180 apartments plus ground floor retail in a multi-million dollar renovation project. Libby had also been seeking City assistance in providing parking for the project.
Reuse of the property site has been a goal of City officials and others since the department store closed in 1995. If put on the market, it is unclear if Libby is prepared to proceed with a renovation project if a buyer is not found. Numerous potential buyers have looked at the building in the past but failed to close on a purchase.
Photo credit: Citysky Photography by Nate Farnsworth.

Holiday spending might be a bit tougher this year, so you better make sure that the gifts are a bit more meaningful. What could be more meaningful that a signed book about Buffalo to give to loved ones who are living out of town at the moment? Or maybe someone has just moved back and is hoping to become more familiar with the area. Even better, why not give a signed Buffalo book to someone who has been talking about moving back. Give them the push that they need... give them one o …
When you think of the holidays, do you think of gingerbread houses? If you don't maybe it's because you never experienced the professionally-made houses featured each year at the historic Gilda's Club mansion on Delaware Avenue. It's a wonderful chance to dive into the holiday season and support a worthy cause at the same time. Here's Christa's take on the event from last season:
For any home cook that likes to make the simplest of candies or decorate cakes, Gilda's Club of WNY w …
Game and word lovers are asked to shake their tile bags and rack their brains while assisting others during Scrabble® Fest 2009, a fundraiser for Literacy Volunteers of Buffalo and Erie County. Literacy Volunteers holds Scrabble® Fest every year in February and March as a means for people to have fun during the dreary winter days and to use words to support literacy.
Specifically, Literacy Volunteers is calling for hosts—anyone in the Buffalo area—to open their homes to …
Whether you’re a competitive runner hoping to finish the 8K course in less than a half-hour, or a recreational runner who plans a leisurely run dressed as a caterpillar or a pink flamingo, the YMCA Turkey Trot is the race for you. For more than a hundred years the YMCA Turkey Trot has attracted countless runners of all abilities to what has become an annual Thanksgiving morning tradition. It is, in fact, the oldest continually run footrace in North America. (Check out this fun T … 





Comment Options
Giovanni_Cent
Not suprised. Haven't heard any updates on the Loft since it was announced over the summer.
Report this
Jas
A major disappointment for Bflo and Main Street. The property is listed as $3,999,999; nearly double the cost of purchase but not a single improvement was made. Hmmmm
Report this
Giovanni_Cent
I know Jas, the owner could at least clean up the windows along Main St. Remove all the graffiti and other markings and have this place LOOK PRESENTABLE. Who wants to buy a dump for that price?
Report this
SLEEPL8
Is Libby crazy or did he just get a great deal that he wants to cash in on? How could that property have appreciated by %100 in the past year? I wonder why he is walking away from his ambitious plans. Could it be that the fabled "down town renaissance" Is a bunch of bullshit? I am going to say all this now before all the comment clones can do it "It will be a great mixed use building with first floor retail" and "we dont need more parking near it...people should ride bikes and take the rail blah blah blah" Good luck finding a buyer. This shit box will sit on the market for a couple years...then when some fool does finally get it they wont be able to do anything with it because their projects will be tied up court for one reason or another. Same shit different day. Go Sabres.
Report this
Jefferson
Sounds like a first rate flipping act.
Report this
sbrof
yeah, he is trying to make a buck without spending a penny.
Report this
Carebear
The Warehouse lofts are right behind this building. They are doing the work first and improving the block.
Report this
urbanesque
What does the "Anti-Flipping" task force have to say about this? Let's see if there is an equitable dispensation of the law across the board.
I am happy to see Richard Libby relinquish this property if he is over his head already. It is better to admit failure and defeat than to prolong the inevitable due to pride and ego.
Report this
urbanxplorer
Demo!
Report this
Hospitable
wow... didn't see that one coming lol, Have never heard of Libby and the lack of updates on the project really made it D.O.A.... something needs to be done with this place, love to see waht that anti flip task forces says about this one haven't really heard much action from them regardless.
This "task-force" would make quite the reputation for themselves if they took this schmuck of a downstater for all he's got..... I'd really like to see someone stand up to these flippers and no-name developers; something needs to be done to better manage out of town owner's..
Report this
Andrew
i wouldn’t really call it flipping. he did nothing to the property. he just bought it sat on it and as sabrof said "make a buck without spending a penny."
Report this
NBJOHN
No flipping goes on in Buffalo
Report this
Fudgeworth
A few comments:
-According to some of your logic, a person that buys a building has to make improvements to it before they can resell it. If they don’t make any improvements, they should sell it for the price at which they bought it for?
-If the guy can raise $2M, I bet he has access to lawyers who told him what he’s doing is legal.
-Just because he lists the selling price at $4M doesn’t mean he’s going to get that price for it.
Check this site out: http://www.buffaloflipping.com/Learn.htm
Report this
TBone
I suspect that last year's "ambitious" loft plans was only a ploy to raise the asking price for the property without improving it.
Report this
magnum
This is great news! Since the current owner thinks it's worth $4 million, let the city raise his property taxes to that assessed value. Obviously, it's going to sit vacant longer(especially at this price), so let this out of towner learn first hand what we think of flippers.
Report this
RonR
A couple of points. First, if this guy is listing the building for 3million he must think he can get it. Because of this, I would say that is a good sign for downtown. Just imagine what he would be listing it at if it was remodeled. Second, if his asking price to high, he is going to have to sit on the building. If this happens I would like to see the taxes for this property go up and the city sick him like a dog on any and every violation possible.
We should have no problem with investors coming in and buying property and selling it with a REALTOR. Doing it this way is way different then buying a home at auction and selling on ebay. Like I said, all of the challenges with this site are well documented. I doubt someone with 4million is going to buy without protection.
Report this
Ross
GREAT!!! Another year summer to enjoy the STENCH pour out of this dump and observe MORE paint jobs and maby even a broken window of two can pop up soon. I'm sure the visitor's, residence's, and workers will enjoy another year of walking past this "what could have been" eyesore... Typical, typical, typical. What did happen to that so called "RENAISSANCE"?????? Souns like B-S
Report this
MikeInWNY
I am ashamed to live in a society that now appears to advocate rules for selling property. The mere suggestion that Libby shouldn't be able to sell the property for more than he paid, unless he makes improvements, smacks of collectivism. The guy invested his money in the building, he owns it, and it is his right to sell it without arcane interference from the urban nazis.
Everybody with their wonderful ideas should either pool their money and purchase some property for redevelopment or keep their yaps shut. People have forgotten long abandoned values, like property rights, that have done more to advance our country than a bunch of people with nothing but ideas and opinions.
Report this
Ross
Don't worry, Mike, this building will soon be in such bad shape, it'll have to be demolished and then we'll listen to everyone say "SAVE IT!" with no takers. Anyone who has peaked in the windows along Main St. can see how bad it looks inside.
Report this
platt4
Oh Ross, now you're sounding like BuffaloFalling. Again.
Report this
divadisintegrator
Like Glinda the Good Witch said, “Come out, come out, wherever you are….” Especially irate metrosexuals...
Hey, Ross, are you stuck in the 90's? Watch too much "Friends?" Otherwise, you'd be using your old sign in - BuffaloFalling....
Report this
RPreskop
Libby is selling the vacant, deteriorated AM@As complex because it is obvious that this old department store has deteriorated to a point of almost no viable return. The reality of the situation here is it will cost him a tremendous fortune just to remove the asbestos and make structural repairs alone not including additional millions required to convert this decrepit eyesore of a department store into luxury condos. It is obviously not a doable project from a financial standpoint. The land AM@As is sitting on is more valuable than the building complex itself. I wish some of these diehard historic preservationists would get it into their thick heads that the old AM@As Building is not worth saving and demolition and clearence of this decrepit, architecturally drab eyesore is not only the right solution but also the only sensible and economically viable solution. It is time to permanently kill dead this idiotic idea of " save old AM@As" because it is not worth saving in the first place. There is absolutely nothing physically beautiful or architecturally significant about this hideous old building complex. Lets tear down this dilapidated old pile of shit and get on with bigger and better things in life.
Report this
nick
Wasn't it also obvious that the Webb building had deteriorated past a viable use? The asbestos will have to be removed whether the building is demolished or rehabiliated so that is a moot issue. If the city actually inforced its laws this building wouldn't be allowed to denegrate to the current situation.
Also, while RPreskop may say there is nothing phyiscally or architecturally significant about the building, this is merely his opinion, research will tell you differently. From Martin Wachadlo's AM&A page on the Buffalo As an Architectural Museum website "The Main Street section was built in 1935 to the design of Starrett & Van Vleck, a major New York architectural firm most noted for their department stores, which included Lord & Taylor, Saks Fifth Avenue, and Bloomingdale's."
Report this
DannyBoy
I agree with RPreskop, this building is NOT Attractive. I'd rather see a bright NEW HIGH RISE take it's place.
Report this
tudorguy
While Libby is free to sell the building, shouldn't he be held responsible for the code violations? I know most of them were there when he purchased however if he's doubling the price, he should still need to do repairs.
Report this
DannyBoy
He probably knows someone at City Hall and is allowed to do what ever he wants...That's how it's done in this town.
Report this
Sal
magnum, THANK YOU for noticing the assessment increases in the City of Buffalo. By not raising the assessment this coming year, the city will lose about $90,000 in property tax revenue.
Report this
RPreskop
nick, Compared to Saks Fifth Avenue, Bloomingdales, and Lord&Taylor flagship stores in New York, the old AM&As is a very mediocre work of architecture. It is clearly an architecturally drab, plane jane building. There is absolutely nothing beautiful about it and there is absolutely nothing significant about it. Due to its advanced deteriorated condition, demolition and clearence is really the only sensible, workable and from a financial standpoint, a feasible solution. Keep an important item in mind, the land that the decrepit AM&As sits on is more valuable than the AM&As complex itself.
Report this
styler
It would be nice to have a 'project ticker' on the internet where Buffalonians could track the progress of projects from public proposals to actual completion. This would be a handy tool for all city managers. Note: I said managers, not leaders.
Report this
nick
I still want to know how it is more economically feasible to demo it and build new, have you seen a feasibility study? Also, I guess the land would be more valuable because our city will pay for the demo hoping someone will invest. I ask again, wasn't the Webb building deteriorated beyond a feasible solution?
Report this
MJWorthington
As for wanting to see a new high rise in its place, I think we wouldn't mind seeing new high rises in any one of the numerous already vacant parcels/surface lots downtown. No need to knock something down to accomplish that task. Especiially without one even proposed.
Report this
JohnB
Didn't Libby, when he first bought this site, make some 500K worth of interior repairs because of code violations? But, was recently slammed with more?
Report this
TBone
A bright new high rise? What makes anyone think that a high rise would be economically viable on that site when any investor would have to put in the costs of demolition?
Report this