DOCOMOMO

The funny
title of this story stands for “Do
cumentation and Conservation of buildings sites and neighborhoods of the Modern Movement. The name is self-descriptive of the
group’s mission.  I bring up this group because frequent BRO writer West
Coast Perspective recently sent me a picture of the Tishman Building showing on
going construction work being done at street level.  The first thing that
popped into my mind was DOCOMOMO
.  

The Tishman
Building is one of a very small number of mid-century works of architecture in
the city.  Apparently the current owners are remodeling the lobby to make
the building more attractive to tenants.  The Tishman building was built
in the 1950′s and was Buffalo’s first major downtown building after the long
drought of WWII and the depression. With its then fantastically modern
skin of glass soaring up from the sidewalk, it was also a radical departure
from every other building in Buffalo at the time.  It is not an
architectural masterpiece, but today remains as a solidly positive contributor
to the urban fabric of downtown Buffalo.  

Thumbnail image for tishman full.png

Aside from
the fact that it replaced a stunningly beautiful Victorian building on this
site, it is hard to find fault with Tishman as a city building.  It fills
its site and provides a great urban wall for Lafayette Square.  Its size
and simple form, along with its contrasting glassiness, makes for a great
partner for the adjacent Deco styled Rand Building.  It has big plate
glass storefront windows that give the building a friendly, open face to
pedestrians.  Its glass skin was very striking in its day.  It was
nothing like anything else in Buffalo at the time.  I am sure it made a
big stir when it opened.  At only 20 stories, this is a tiny building as
far as skyscrapers go but the architects used a simple trick to give it a much
bigger presence.  By breaking up the shear glass walls with smaller window
pains, the building appears to be twice as tall–giving it a much more powerful
presence on the street.  

Alas,
Tishman is now well into its most dangerous period of existence as a building.
 By the time many buildings reach 40 or so years in age, they start to
fade.  They no longer reside on the “A” list of properties.
 Their initial tenants have often moved on.  They can no longer
provide the amenities demanded by society, and often their architectural style
is seen as tired and dated.

Imagine
yourself back when Tishman first presented its slick modernism to Buffalo.
 It probably instantly transformed Buffalo’s impression of what an office
building should be. Buildings of an earlier era would have looked dull in
comparison.  The mid-century was a time when people yearned for clean
modern buildings.  It was a time when the rush was on to get rid of all
the dark old buildings and replace them with new buildings with new modern
materials, materials that matched the new technological age of mid-century. At
this same time, the storefront facades of old Main Street were also being
covered with extravaganzas of modernism not unlike the architecture of the
popular world’s fairs of the time. Tishman joined in by replacing the wonderful
old and tired German Insurance Building and so on. 

Now Tishman
has reached that critical building lifetime threshold.  Its original
tenant is gone.  It is too small, has no parking, and its once high-tech
skin is no longer the marvel of modernism it used to be.  Therefore, when
I saw the renovation picture of this building, my first reaction was worry.
  Will this owner make improvements to this building that are in keeping
with its original architecture, or will some ill-conceived
“improvement” be made?  Only time will tell, but if history is a
guide, the “improvements” to this now aged building may be less than
stellar.  

Mid-century
modern architecture is the poor orphan child of the preservation movement.
 Many don’t recognize these buildings as a part of an important heritage
worth protecting.  They don’t have the highly handcrafted, highly detailed
forms that older buildings have, and they have only recently fallen on harder
times.  With so many older buildings in distress, it is often hard to
focus on newer structures that are also in need of preservation.  Buffalo
has never had a large collection of mid century architecture and already a vast
majority of what was here is gone.  

Virtually
all of the modern retail facades on Main Street have been removed, and the old
modern AM&A store hangs on by a thread.  This is the reason that
DOCOMOMO
 was started.  The preservation
of modern architecture is a growing issue throughout the US and the world.
 Early efforts at calling attention to the plight of modernist works of
architecture were tenuous and were not treated seriously by the public and
government agencies.  The movement has gained a lot of momentum in recent
years but, even today, the struggle to impress on people the importance these
buildings represent to our heritage is an uphill battle.  A Google search
results in many articles on the subject.  Almost every city in the country
has been faced with the issue of loss to its collection of mid-century
heritage.  Seeing this happen to buildings from my youth gives me new
insight into how we decimated our earlier heritage so easily. Here is a
small sample.

Interesting
side note:  There is a slightly larger twin to the Tishman Building in
Cleveland
at 1717 East 9th Street.
 Both buildings were erected in 1959
according to the Emporis database.

A few sample
mid-century preservation stories:

Here @ Illinois

Here @ Ecoabsence

Here @ Dallas

Here @ Commercial Appeal

About the author  ⁄ shanahan.julia

18 comments
DOC
DOC

This is one of the best posts I have read in a while, Steel. I want to remind all of those who are posting in support of this mid-century beauty of the other mid-century beauties you so capriciously malign (e.g., the turquoise green and aluminum high rise apartment buildings on Delaware Ave.. Those buildings, and others, have just as much heritage as the Guarantee building and the Richardson Complex. And they are in full use.

STEEL
STEEL

It sits back from the street too far and half the block is covered with parking.

johnnywalker
johnnywalker

The problem with the Tishman is that its entrance faces southwest. No building in buffalo should have a SW facing entrance come Jan,Feb, etc. Moe the etrance to the other side.

YKYF
YKYF

Its site plan? How so?

STEEL
STEEL

YKF Good point. This story is not really just about Tishman.

Donovan is actually a nice building. Its site plan is the problem

flyguy
flyguy

I for one will not regret the Donovan.

YKYF
YKYF

I find this thread about such a modest project distracting and beside the point while the ECHDA is preparing to demolish The Donovan Office Building - one of few examples in Buffalo of the Modern Movement/International Style. We'll eventually regret this too!

scarmina
scarmina

Responding to "Shoestring".....our plan is to remove all of the dark film on the first floor windows and install blinds. Unfortunately the glazing technology at the time this building was constructed did not address heat gain very well. We feel strongly that all first floors need to be transparent, however the blinds will be a must.

sonyactivision
sonyactivision

That claim would belong to the Liberty Bank Building but this one could vie with the Avant.

Buffalo Rising
Buffalo Rising

Tishman Building Adding Curb Appeal

The New York City-based owners of the Tishman Building are upgrading the property to help attract new tenants.  The prominent Lafayette Square office building has 198,000 sq.ft. of space spread over 20 floors.  Built in 1958 by Tishman Realty...

queencity
queencity

I dont think this was a solidly positive factor at all. The Tishman replaced the German American Insurance Building...a full cast iron facade...that rivaled anything built in any other city.

The Tishman was a really nice addition to our city but as with many other modern buildings like Main Place Mall, the M&T and others....they were built in the wrong place.

Had these buildings been built in another location...we could today have our 20th century masterpieces alongside our midcentury and tomorrows modern.

Instead...we are left with a downtown fabric that is only a shadow of what it was and what it should be

Shoestring Budget
Shoestring Budget

"a solidly positive contributor to the urban fabric of downtown Buffalo."

Hardly. It offers dark blank walls to the street at one of Buffalo's most important intersections, though maybe that is what is being changed.

benfranklin
benfranklin

I did some work for National Fuel when they called this home. The entrance was nothing more than a hallway, with a desk for a gaurd, you made a left to get to the elevators. The majority of the first floor was used as a walk-in/retail area for customers. You couldn't (easily) gain access to the elevators from the retail area. There was a certain unspoken unease about unhappy customers possibly gaining access to executives with seven figure salaries (published periodically back then by the News). In my opinion, that as much as anything else lead to them heading to Amherst.

flyguy
flyguy

Thanks for the info! I agree this address could be something again ( :

scarmina
scarmina

Our firm, Carmina Wood Morris, PC has been retained by Solil Management, the building owner, to "update" the entry and lobby of the building. We have been very careful to respect the monumentality of the building and to create a final design which will meet our clients goal to attract new tenants to this corner of Main Street. The main goal of the design is to modernize the lobby, with new lighting, a Concierge and Building Directory. The entrance is being "pulled out" flush with the facade to help bring more natural light into the lobby while eliminating the "smokers paradise" under the soffit. The storefront will remain monumental and a revolving door will be part of this new design. I will forward to Chris a couple of renderings which will be placed on the temporary partition soon. We are also adding a second floor conference center and dining area which will be an amenity to all tenants in the building. Solil is making a substantial investment in this building to attract new tenants. We are fortunate for that commitment.

nick
nick

Does anyone have photos of the lobby to see what may be lost? I feel these buildings are starting to gain more acceptance and begining to be rehabbed in a way that embraces the openess and stark beauty of the mid-century modern movement. I hope the alterations to the lobby do not sacrifice the building's character for minimal gains.

townline
townline

This building could be THE condo address to have in Buffalo.

© 2014 Hyperlocal Media. All Rights Reserved.